Previous Entry | Next Entry

allaire: (gaypic)
Something's really been bugging me about a lot of the Numb3rs and NCIS stories I've been reading recently, and finally, I can define what it is and put it into words.

It's this sense of entitlement by family, friends and colleagues that they have an indisputable right to delve into a family member/friend/colleague's life, thoughts, feelings, and secrets, and that the person they force to spill what they'd originally intended to keep to themselves should be grateful for their nosiness and the emotional blackmail.

And the really surprising thing? At least in fan fiction, it works. All. The. Time.

Don Eppes doesn't want to talk about the emotional repercussions of a bad case? Too bad. Megan Reeves (or Terry Lake), his partner, wants to hear how he feels. It doesn't matter whether or not Don is ready to talk. She's entitled; after all, she's a profiler, and his mental state is her concern. If he hesitates, she either freezes him out - thus making him feel like he has to apologize and spill his secrets - or threatens to report him (and his shaky mental health) to his superiors.

Tony DiNozzo doesn't want to talk about his feelings regarding the train wreck of his broken relationship with Jeanne Benoit? Too bad. Ziva wants to make him feel better, and to achieve that, she needs to hear how he feels first. She's his partner, and she has secret ninja skills (meaning she can lift his keys from his pockets, pick the lock to his apartment, or just incessantly bug him at work). Considering Gibbs' famously small tolerance for his agents "goofing off" on company time, for the sake of peace and quiet either Tony or Ziva will have to give in. With Ziva's pathological need to be more macho than her male colleagues, Tony spills his secrets, only to end up being thankful to have somebody listen to his woes.

Seriously, what the fuck?!

What kind of skewed world view is that?! Thoughts are not only free, they're also private.

Anybody tries that passive-aggressive bullshit on me, I'll let them stew in silence. It should always, always be up to the one in emotional distress whether or not (s)he talks to someone, trusts someone enough to talk to them, or heck, just feels up to talking about it at all at this point in time, period.

Of course I'd like to know that a friend is willing to lend me a sympathetic ear. But please at the time of my own choosing. Whereas emotional blackmail? A big no-no, and a sure friendship breaker.

Oh God, I so need a healthier fandom.

:::headdesk:::

Comments

(Anonymous) wrote:
Jul. 7th, 2008 07:58 am (UTC)
Word! I´m not so much into Numb3rs but you are spot on with NCIS. And I´m not surprised it shows up in fanfic- hey, it´s canon!
Though you forgot to mention Abby- you know, from the ep Suspicion "Oh everybody has one, I'm not gonna tell you mine... what's yours?", the whole thing regarding MOAS.
I remember sitting there and just thinking WTF??!??! Seriously, I can´t decide who was more hypocritical, Abby or Ziva.
I´d like to say it´s a bunch of writers not being able to write decent female characters (the "I´m so superior it´s not even funny anymore" came up with Kate as well) but I guess it´s them not being able to write Tony standing up for himself and sticking to it. I can fanwank a lot of Tony´s reactions by keeping the fact in mind he´s the poster boy for an ACA (Adult Child of Alcoholics) but since they established in one of the earlier episodes he has no issues with moving on (from both Cities and Squads) I´m waiting for them to explain why Tony´s still hanging around (and hoping they deal with stuff in season 6; finally).
*sheepish grin, getting off soapbox* sorry for hijacking your lj. Guess that´s one of the reasons I´m usually just lurking on lj...
[identity profile] allaire.livejournal.com wrote:
Jul. 7th, 2008 05:16 pm (UTC)
I'm glad you feel the same way! :-)
And don't worry about venting here - that's what lj is for (as long as it still exists as a fannish forum, that is *eg*).

I started resenting Ziva with her actions regarding the guestlist for her 'team' dinner, and she hasn't given me many reasons that would endear her to me since. She's a good and solid agent and colleague, yes, but a friend to Tony? Not so much.

Kate I initially liked, until her 'teasing' of Tony started to become maliciously cutting instead of funny.

As for Abby? Usually I like her, but sometimes she behaves so thoughtlessly... or, like you said, like a hypocrite. The MOAS thing didn't irritate me quite that much, but forcing McGee to take Jethro (= the dog) through emotional blackmail? That wasn't okay. Plus I resent that she always defends Gibbs and - despite their close relationship - never stands up to him on behalf of the others.

I'd also love to see Tony's character draw the conclusions from how he's been treated over the last 4 years and leave, but then we'd lose him on the show. Damn. I'd adore a spin-off, sigh.

I'd settle for an honest, deeply-meant apology from Gibbs, and a meaningful expression of his regard for Tony. On screen.

Not that that's ever going to happen.

/rant

Sorry!

favorites

Latest Month

February 2017
S M T W T F S
   1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728    
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios
Designed by [personal profile] chasethestars